Best Pizza in Toms River, New Jersey
31 pizza are listed in Toms River, NJ. None has 3 counted reviews yet, so there is no ranking; the first reviews decide it. Every review shows how it was collected and whether the customer was verified, and paying never changes a position. How scores work · markdown
Pizza listed in Toms River, NJ
Nobody here has three counted reviews yet, so there is no ranking; the list is alphabetical within the score. Know one of these businesses? Your review starts its score.
- Al's ice creamToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Antonio's Italian RestaurantToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Attilio'sToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Capone's Gourmet Pizza & PastaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Cuzzins Pizzeria and RestaurantToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- DiCosmo's PizzaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Floyd's Brick Oven PizzaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Frankie G's PizzaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Giampapa's PizzeriaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- J Leno's Pizzeria & RestaurantToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Joey D's PizzaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Linda's PizzaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Little Mia's PizzaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Mellow MushroomToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Mia's Pizza 37Toms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Midtown PizzeriaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Naples Pizza and RestaurantToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Picasso's II Pizza and ItalianToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Pies On 37Toms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Pizza and PaniniToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Pondrelli's Pizza And KitchenToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Sal & Jimmy's PizzaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Schiano's PizzaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Sila BellaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Slice HouseToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Steverino's PizzeriaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Sunrise PizzeriaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- The Real PizzaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Veraces PizzaToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Villaggio Pizza Toms RiverToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
- Vito's Pizza & PubToms River, NJno reviews yet · write one
Choosing pizza in Toms River, NJ
Restaurant reviews age fast: chefs, owners and menus change. For a pizza business, read the last three months, look for mentions of consistency across visits, and give weight to reviews that describe a specific dish, a specific service failure, and how staff responded.
Worth checking before you call
- Recent reviews, within the last few months, not the all-time average.
- Health inspection results, published by most county or city health departments.
- How complaints were handled on the spot, according to reviews.
- Accuracy of hours, reservations and delivery times.
- Allergy and dietary handling if that matters to you.
Questions people ask
- How are pizza in Toms River, NJ ranked here?
- By the same Bayesian score shown on each profile: every business starts at 3.5, a review's weight halves every 90 days, verified customers count fully and unverified reviews at 60 percent, and reviews from the business's own staff are excluded. A business needs 3 counted reviews to hold a position; until then it is listed without one. Nothing a business pays for enters the calculation.
- Why do some pizza here have no score yet?
- Because fewer than 3 customers have reviewed them on RooVello. The directory lists businesses from public map data with their websites so the first review has somewhere to land; a profile earns a score as reviews arrive.
- Why does a popular pizza business have an Average score?
- High volume brings more mixed reviews, and the score here weighs recent ones most. Read the recent reviews; a dip often marks a change in kitchen or ownership.
- Are restaurant reviews verified?
- When the restaurant sends review requests tied to orders or reservations, yes. Many restaurant reviews are organic and unverified; they count at reduced weight and stay out of the verified-only score.

